A federal judge blocked part of the new “medically frail” rule

On October 29, a federal judge in Boston blocked part of the federal rule that narrowed who counts as “medically frail.” The judge said the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services went beyond the law by requiring people with a qualifying condition to also prove that it significantly limits their ability to meet the work requirement.

The judge left other parts of the rule in place. States can still reject proof of a medical condition if the diagnosis is more than a year old, and can still accept only one self-attestation of medical frailty per continuous enrollment period. The ruling does not strike down the Medicaid reporting requirements themselves.

The case was brought by 25 states and the District of Columbia. We don’t yet know how the ruling applies in Montana, or whether the federal government will appeal. We’ll update this page when the state says more.

Why it matters: If the narrower standard stays blocked, people with a qualifying health condition may be able to keep the “medically frail” exemption without also having to prove the condition limits their ability to work.

What to do: Don’t wait for the state to sort this out. If you think you may be medically frail, ask your provider to help you document it, and answer any state notice by the deadline on the letter.

Related: June 1, 2026: New federal rules set out who counts as “medically frail” · Could I be exempt?

Sources: PBS NewsHour, Oct. 30, 2026 · NBC News, Oct. 30, 2026

Get a text when there’s an update. Sign up

Something going wrong?

A letter that never came? Hours that didn’t get reported? Tell us what’s happening.

We care.

We’re caregivers and neighbors helping each other through the new rules. In our Facebook group, people ask questions, share what worked, and look out for each other.

We care.

We’re caregivers and neighbors helping each other through the new rules. In our Facebook group, people ask questions, share what worked, and look out for each other.

“

Even if you don’t personally rely on health care, I know you know someone that does. Our friends, family, and neighbors need this funding to have access to the vital medical supports they need.”

Jasmine Schmidt, Butte

“

Even if you don’t personally rely on health care, I know you know someone that does. Our friends, family, and neighbors need this funding to have access to the vital medical supports they need.”

Jasmine Schmidt, Butte